Steam Water Hammer Accident Investigation and Steam Training


Kirsner Consulting Engineering logo
Wayne Kirsner, P.E. / Principal

Water Hammer Quiz

1. To have a water hammer event in a steam system, you must have a large-volume flow of fast-moving steam.



(TRUE | FALSE)


images

2. Condensate lying dormant in a steam system that is suddenly exposed to steam can flash causing a type of “waterhammer” over pressurization.

3. Fast flowing steam picking up a slug of condensate and flinging it against an elbow is not, technically, water hammer.

Can a collision of this type actually rupture a pipe?


(YES | NO)


4. When steam becomes totally enveloped in cool condensate so that it rapidly condenses, it's pressure drastically:

5. Is water hammer _________ likely in an uninsulated steam line? Why?

6. You have two valves to choose from in the shop -- a Class 150 valve or a Class 250 Valve (both of which are labeled on the valve body casting); which is more resistant to failure in the event of a water hammer?

Waterhammer that shattered a Class 250 Cast Iron Valve killing an operator.

7. Saturated steam flowing over pooled condensate will eventually evaporate it, if given enough time.

8. You're replacing a 3/4" bucket trap with another from the same manufacturer. The cast iron bodies are identical and marked with raised letters on the castings indicating 250 psi. The older trap worked just fine in your 225 psi steam system until it failed. There’s no reason the new trap shouldn't work just fine too.

10. Suppose you determine that THERE IS pooled condensate upstream of the valve residing in the pressurized line. What’s the most important thing to do before opening the Valve to avoid a water hammer? (choose the correct answer below)

11. What's wrong with the design of the steam piping in the diagram above?

12. Suppose you elect to use an infrared gun to measure pipe temperature. What two factors MUST you be aware of to get an accurate temperature measurement using an infrared gun?

13. When a section of steam line is isolated and allowed to cool to room temperature, the most important reason to open a drain valve and leave it open is -- (choose the correct answer below)

image

14. During warm-up/start-up of a 350' long 10" cold steam main from 62 F to the saturated steam temperature of 142 psig steam (362 F), about 450 #'s of condensate will form in less than 5 minutes in the steam line. If air is vented but no drain is opened and only a trap at the low point in the line is to be relied upon to drain the condensate to the condensate return system, roughly what percentage of the warm-up condensate load will accumulate in the line before the trap begins to discharge any condensate?


15. The steam trap at right has failed closed. Noting the position of the valves, how high can the level of condensate be expected to build over time in the vertical rise?


16 What’s the most likely reason for the trap failure?


17. If the steam in the Main were superheated, would condensate still build-up in the lines shown if the trap failed?


(YES | NO)


19. The water surrounding a steam main in a flooded manhole is boiling. What's likely going on inside the steam main?



Is this dangerous? Why?


The next two questions deal with Column-Closure Waterhammer

20. Pumped condensate from a receiver rises on its way to the Plant Condensate Receiver.


When condensate in the receiver is relatively cool during low steam loads, there's no problem. But at high steaming loads, condensate tank temperature exceeds 200 F (so that vapor pressure of the condensate exceeds 11.4 psia). In this condition, every time the condensate pump starts, there's a big "bang" which violently shakes the pipe riser and downcomer.


What's happening when the pump cycles off?

Would adding a "soft start" variable speed drive to the pump motor:

Would a vacuum breaker added at the top of the system help?


(NO | YES)


The key to understanding Column-Closure waterhammer is understanding "Vapor Pressure". Specifically, that if the pressure on condensate falls below the "vapor pressure" of the condensate, the water column will separate.

image

If you got a lot of questions WRONG on this Quiz, that's what was supposed to happen. In many instances, the Quiz is designed to bring to light misconceptions about waterhammer in steam systems which have been repeated so many times, they've become "Conventional Wisdom".


Waterhammer Seminars

Share by: